A Possible Addition to the Rules?

Hello,
I'm sure that many of you have seen my ban appeal and how I mentioned I would like to suggest a rule about being able to attack anyone if they initiated combat with you. I think we should add a rule that says"If someone attacks you in PvP, you have full rights to fight back, no matter if you warped to the area or not." I think its a little silly that people can't defend themselves if they warped somewhere and are attacked. It just doesn't make sense that they don't have the option of protecting themselves without breaking a rule and getting banned. This is just my opinion on the topic. Thoughts?
Sincerely,
_Flagellum

 

If were adding on to pvp rules we should also make it illegal to log out in an enemy pvp town after killing all of its members, which you seem to enjoy doing

 

You know what the funny thing is _flag, you had so much time to leave the town without someone attacking you. You kept going forward deeper into the town when someone was already attacking you; you could have just left... The server is already complicated enough with the rules we have...seriously, the logic in the debate of this is so complicated and unnecessary.

 

i agree with flag

 

God guys, chill out. I was just offering up an idea. I don't need to be roasted by everyone. You think I don't feel bad enough without you guys tearing me down, too? As for you, Quiet, I don't know my way around Farside. I've been there twice. It is also rather difficult to figure a way out with someone on you heels with a diamond sword. Also, the logic isn't difficult at all. They attack you, you can attack back. Seems pretty simple. And as for you, Mexicans, its perfectly legal. I've talked to admins about it numerous times, so don't try to start s***. All I can say is that I apparently thought that I had more true friends on this server than it seems. Next time I guess I'll think twice before trying to better the server.

 

I do kinda agree with _flag on this one, but still, then we'd have the problem of people going to other towns, trying to start people til they initiate the attack. Also, I think the thing that you can only pvp if your last warp was either your own /t spawn or /warp pvp is a tad extreme. /home, if it is your home, should be included at least.

 

Sorry flag but I disagree with you on this one. If you enter someone else's town through a /town spawn, or any other kind of warp, then you are subject to the no /warp to attack the town. Also, the definition of 'attack' means "any physical damage done to any player from the defending nation" whether or not you started it.

 

No. As an assistant of DarkFire I don't want enemies running around our towns and getting the feel of the town. That would just make their raids more well planned out. However, that is in-evadable and completely okay as long as you DON'T use the town's /t spawn or a /home to get to the town.

Also you shouldn't go to an enemy town to pall around in raiding gear.

You can log out after you leave the town legally. Not in the town. You should never log out in an enemy town.

EDIT: I can see you're point with /home's as long as it is before the battle starts (I.E. before the attacker is there). As for town spawn's, you should only use them for battle if it is your own town's spawn or a town in your nation's spawn.

 

Still unsure about the /home thing. So I have to walk for 30 minutes to be able to defend my home? Oh okay, sounds reasonable enough ಠ_ಠ

 

*facepalm*

Can we pretend I posted that before you're edit?

 

you posted that more like 5 hours after

 

SHHHH!!!! Let's just pretend

 

This needs to be added

 

And I realised what I was meant to ask, if our actual home is a /warp, does that make it illegal to defend my home?

 

Do you guys really need me to go into detail on everything allowed or can you use your common sense?

If you being attacked in the neutral or friendly wilderness (I.E. not an enemy base) and you warped there you can attack back.

If you warp anywhere that isn't inside an enemy town or base and they start attacking you can attack. If you are lured to warp to an enemy town/base that is a different story.

Let's say this rule happens. You warp to an enemy town when nobody but noobs are on. They start attacking you because they know you are an enemy. You easily kill them. It just creates loop holes around warping for PvP. Especially with towns that take a long time to get to legally, like Morningstar, Crucible, Molten, and Ulair.

If you want to go to an enemy territory talk to who ever is in charge of the town/base before you warp there and make an peace agreement. Screen shot it, and have them tell their allies to not attack you either.

 

Do we not have a PvP committee for this stuff

 

Its called pvp council, a board you guys cannot see.

 

Thanks sharq

 

Yes, we do have PvP council, but most of them are inactive. I think I've explained why I think the rules should not be put in place. What are your reasons for wanting it?