Ksapple107 AA

I can change to a no if it's a tie.

 

This thread still open?

 

Do you see it being locked?

 

Still open.. Stiiiill open

 

Well...im sorry but i dont think your build is arch worthy. The Statues inside are really nice but the exterior design is very repetive and i think the colour design of the outside just doesnt look good :/. There are too many blocks who just dont fit together and you made a new design for every line. For me it looks like you just desperately tried to add more detail in the walls. And i need to say that i dont see any detail in the roof at all . But the shape of your build is really nice. So i would recommend what some other people recommend too. Start a new build and maybe try to focus more on statues this time. I definitely see the potential for arch.
I hope this doesnt sounds too rude, but from me its a no.

 

No no! Not rude at all, thankyou and yes I have already started a large statue that i hope will match the scale of one of peterian's outside warp peter. Maybe even bigger! (Doubt that)

 

*So there has been little to no activity on this thread, is there a verdict with a tie? (No, I don't mean one of you switches to a no or switches to a yes ). Or should we wait for more replies..?* -There are many, many, many Architects who have not yet replied here or on many other threads for that matter.

idk, imaxorz

 

A yes from there, there are huge improvements. Honestly, i'm not a big fan of the build and I think the colors take away from the skills and such put there, but I think you are arch worthy, you just need a less overwhelming color scheme xD

 

so 5 yeses and 4 nos so far, thankyou lionfish

 

Still 5 for yes and 4 no

 

Finally Finished the Main Form of my Latest Statue (forgot to hit "f1", but doesn't everyone love to hear about how wonderful Pieman_Is_God is?

 

Finish the statue 100% and then bump the thread again, there is no need to constantly bump this. Nothing will change until you finish the statue and even then people may keep with their original verdicts. Also, there is no need to tag staff in the post all the time.

 

Woah.. alrighty then

Im sure pieman wouldnt mind

What do u mean by bump the thread? Make a new one?

 

i think it would be best to make a new thread, but not now and not tomorrow. also if you maybe dont like it, this arch app has failed and you should finish your statue and maybe make one more project and then apply again

 

Yeah but dont i have more yeses than nos?

Sent from my SGH-I747M using Tapatalk 4

 

yeah... but that doesnt mean youll get arch automatically... when you look around you see that most accepted arch apps are like 9 yes and 2 no...
i wouldnt give up yet... but i dont think too that you can keep this thread alive for a much longer time...

 

I'm sure he wouldn't mind, but thats beside the point. Bumping the thread is simply posting in it, let us know that you've finished it and we can look over the application again. Good luck.

 

Hm, I would like to hear it from max. I totally get what you're saying but I need to be sure before I end up having to do another thread.

Sent from my SGH-I747M using Tapatalk 4

 

I can't seem to get through to max though, i have started a conversation and tagged him before but ive gotten nothing. Anyone know an easier way i can reach him or maybe someone else can? Please and thankyou

Sent from my SGH-I747M using Tapatalk 4

 

Max is just very busy, it may be that he has seen it but saw what we have all wrote and agrees. Don't worry about fishing for more opinions now, the descision isn't particularly clear cut at the moment so your best bet is to finish the statue and pretty up the area around it. Once you've done that, bump the thread and we'll review it again.